Skip to main content

Emotion vs. Logic



1 Samuel 30:1–31:13

Reacting is easy. What’s difficult is overcoming emotions especially in a time of adversity. Although emotions are not bad, they can lead us astray. By the same token, when we go too far in the other direction and rely entirely on reason, we risk acting without empathy. The answer to this dilemma is not to use emotions against reason, but to pray instead.

Throughout his life King David struggles to balance emotion and logic. At times he was emotionally wrecked; at other times he is so calculated that he seems heartless. Yet when he sought the Lord in prayer, even when it would be more convenient not to do so, he was better off. 

In 1 Samuel 30:1–6, David returned to the town of Ziklag to find that his two wives along with the wives of his warriors had been captured, and the city had been burned down. The Bible describes the emotional atmosphere that existed: “David and the people who were with him raised their voices and wept until there was not enough strength in them to weep.”  David’s men were so upset that they considered killing him because they believed that the situation was his fault (1 Sam 30:4, 6). Then the Bible records David's decision, “But David strengthened himself in Yahweh his God” (1 Sam 30:6). This decision changed everything.

In seeking Yahweh, David learned that he would be able to overtake the raiders of Ziklag and recover the captives (1 Sam 30:7–10). En route an amazing thing happened: David and his men showed kindness to a stranger, who responded by showing them where the raiders are camped. David and his men then defeated the raiders and recovered the captives (1 Sam 30:11–20). This is one of God's mysterious works. But could God have worked in mysterious ways if David had allowed either hot emotion or cold logic to rule him? Probably not. His prayer made all the difference.


We overcome the problems we face because God works in us, through His Spirit, when we seek Him in prayer. This is also how we can overcome our weaknesses and become more like Him.

What emotions do you need to overcome through prayer?
What tensions can be resolved through God’s work?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hearing and doing I'm amazed at how easy it becomes to nod our heads at all the right places after serving God for a while. We are quick to agree when someone speaks to us about God's Word (given that it is sound doctrine of course), without asking ourselves if it is merely theory to us. The fact of the matter is that most of us believe what the Bible teaches with all our hearts. How is it then that we so easily fall into the trap of knowing but not applying? Hearing but not doing? How do we keep ourselves from thinking we know it all but hold on to a zeal for God's Word that leads to obedience? It is relatively easy to read the 'thou shalt not' passages, to apply it and to tap ourselves on the shoulder thinking we did well! Of course we are doing well if we abstain from all the things we know is bad for us - sinful behaviors, unhealthy attitudes, etc. - but I do think there is more to living a life of abundance and victory! There are many pas...

Temporary Suffering

Temporary Suffering Part 1: Is it God's will for Christians to suffer? I recently posed this question to our congregation. The response could not have been more diverse, ranging from " absolutely ," to " absolutely not! " Here's the thing: everyone undergoes suffering in some form at some point of time. Consequently everyone has an opinion about it, seeing as we're all experts in our own rights. But what does the Bible say? If we take seriously Jesus' words in the Gospels it becomes abundantly clear that being His follower comes with various hardships. His teaching about suffering as a disciple culminates in everyone's least favourite promise in the Bible where He states, " In this world you will have trouble... " (John 16:33) But perhaps that's still somewhat open to interpretation? And what about God's will regarding such matters as suffering and hardship? Let's look at passages out of the letters of...

Refocus

1 Peter 2:1–2 We can't solve every problem, but sometimes we can resolve issues by simply readjusting our focus i.e. seeing them in a different light.   In his first letter, Peter could have focused on people’s sin and their need to repent. But then their attention would be on the problem, and not on solving it. So he shifts the focus: “Therefore, ridding yourselves of all malice and all deceit and hypocrisy and envy and all slander, like newborn infants long for the unadulterated spiritual milk, so that by it you may grow up to salvation” (1 Pet 2:1–2). Peter calls them to see their Christian experience as a newborn longing for milk. They must make the Bible a priority so that it becomes something they need and long for. As they imbibe it, their sinful behavior is resolved. We can always choose where to place our attention. We often turn our attention toward preventing something like sin at the expense of actually doing something good i.e. growing in the Lord. ...